There have been a variety of different reactions to Nintendo’s recent announcement that they will be releasing an HD version of the Wind Waker on the Wii U. These reactions have ranged from surprised to excited, from confused to disappointed.
I think it’s great news for the shear fact that a lot of people who missed out on Wind Waker will be exposed to it for the first time, but there is one point of contention that I’d like to discuss and that is how the game looks; more specifically how it may differ from the already-released stills to the final product.
Wind Waker HD isn’t just a port of the game running at a higher resolution (a.k.a. Dolphin style); it’s a remake of the game. It’s unclear whether the game will be a complete remake (like what happened with Ocarina of Time 3D) or if it will just be spruced up (I suspect the latter), but there are some pretty obvious changes to the visual style that have upset more than a few people who love the game for its art direction (don’t worry friends; we’ll always have the original and Dolphin).
However, there’s no real reason for such an uproar, at least not yet.
One of my first reactions to the announcement, after being surprised by it coming out of left-field, was how something seemed off about the promotional screens that Nintendo released in conjunction with their presentation.
After taking a closer look at the stills, it seems unlikely that they represent the game’s final look.
For starters, the majority of the screens featured a bloom effect that made all the stills seem more like a test of the Wii U’s lighting capabilities than actual in-game footage (Aonuma did say the decision to make Wind Waker HD came about after performing such tests on older games)
This is further suggested by the textures on the character models. While the environment’s textures have been cleaned up (i.e. high resolution, less pixelation when stretched, etc.), the textures on the Link and Tetra models have not (or at least nothing beyond a negligible amount). I’ve ripped enough game models to know what these characters look like without the cel-shading, I know what they look like without lighting, and due to the large number of fan rendering projects, most of us know what these models look like in long-render lighting tests.
These stills look like such tests, specifically tests where the only change is the lighting set-up and the lack of cel-shaders.
And that’s what it all comes down to, the lack of cel-shading. However, if these stills really are just initial HD tests by the Nintendo team, there’s still a chance that the final product will have the proper shaders.
As for the also controversial bloom effect, this too is taken out of context.
This apparent lighting test could be a collection of multiple images of one moment in time, as viewed from multiple cameras within a single scene, and if we all think back to the last time we all played Wind Waker, we’ll remember that a similar lighting effect was present from time to time, however brief. For those who have forgotten, in Wind Waker outside areas appeared too bright upon exiting darker interiors in order to create the illusion of what happens with the human eye in real life. The overexposed lighting in the stills could be a representation of that moment, and it’s unlikely that the remake’s lighting be overexposed for every moment of play (at least within the day cycle).
This could all just be wishful thinking on my part (I do love the cel-shading), and the final game will indeed look like the stills. However, it’s still worth keeping a weary eye out now to prepare ourselves to look for any differences upon the game’s eventual release.
More GenGAME Articles on Zelda Wii U
- Zelda Wii U: Tap Into Everything That Made A Link to the Past Great
- Zelda Wii U: Cooperative Multiplayer is the Next-Gen Revolution We’ve All Been Waiting For
- Zelda Wii U: Non-Linearity is More Than Just Dungeon Order, Has to be the Heart and Soul of the Game
- Wind Waker Wii U is the Perfect Opportunity to Release a Complete Director’s Cut
- Wind Waker Wii U: Will Nintendo Anger Zelda Fans…Again?